Articles by Utopia Support

Prisoner deportations defended

Monday 5 March 2018 | Published in Regional

Australian Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull has defended his government’s policy of deporting New Zealanders who have served more than a cumulative year in prison.

New Zealand News Dispatches Depature cards on the way out

Monday 5 March 2018 | Published in Regional

Paper-based departure cards for people leaving the country could be removed by Christmas, Statistics New Zealand says.

No government mandate for Cook Islands UN seat

Monday 5 March 2018 | Published in Letters to the Editor

Dear Editor,

New virus strain set to be used on rabbits

Monday 5 March 2018 | Published in Regional

NEW ZEALAND – New Zealand is planning to release a rabbit virus across the country, in an attempt to cull the ballooning wild population.

Passing judgement

Monday 5 March 2018 | Published in Letters to the Editor

Dear Editor,

Dual name suggested for Gisborne's bay

Monday 5 March 2018 | Published in Regional

NEW ZEALAND – A Gisborne councillor says a decision to have both Maori and English names for the city’s bay doesn’t go far enough and the name Poverty Bay should be dropped entirely.

Backlash against pastor

Monday 5 March 2018 | Published in Letters to the Editor

Dear Editor,In regards to the backlash against Ngarima George over his thoughts on Jacinda Ardern – the reaction against the Pastor is typical when someone stands up on God's Word.

Report by Jamie Tahana in Papua New Guinea for RNZI

Monday 5 March 2018 | Published in Regional

PAPUA NEW GUINEA – For nearly a week, Isaac Pulupe and seven of his family members have been living under a bit of canvas stretched between the remnants of his house, with little food, dirty water and no electricity.

DNA study sheds light on Pacific settlement

Monday 5 March 2018 | Published in Regional

PACIFIC – A study of ancient DNA has shed light on the epic journeys that led to the settlement of the Pacific by humans.

Minister arrested for fraud

Monday 5 March 2018 | Published in Regional

TONGA – Tonga’s Minister of Internal Affairs, ‘Akosita Lavulavu, and her husband, former cabinet minister ‘Etuate Lavulavu, were arrested on Saturday on fraud related charges.

How can we best protect Suwarrow?

Monday 5 March 2018 | Published in Environment

BirdLife International is a global partnership of conservation organisations (NGOs) that strives to conserve birds, their habitats and global biodiversity, while working with people towards sustainability in the use of natural resources. They are the largest and most influential bird conservation organisation in the world.

Tens of thousands in need of aid

Monday 5 March 2018 | Published in Regional

PAPUA NEW GUINEA – Tens of thousands of people in Papua New Guinea are in urgent need of supplies after last Monday’s powerful earthquake, aid agencies say.

Ardern team embarks on 'Pacific reset'

Monday 5 March 2018 | Published in Regional

PACIFIC – The New Zealand government has kicked off what it calls the “Pacific reset”, with Jacinda Ardern beginning her first trip to the region as Prime Minister.

Another Bachop in the pipeline

Monday 5 March 2018 | Published in Rugby Union

Cook Islander Jackson Garden-Bachop is expected to make his first appearance for the Hurricanes this weekend in the match against the Jaguares.

Premium content

Spreading the 'economic gospel'

Monday 5 March 2018 | Published in Letters to the Editor

Dear Editor, Listening this Thursday morning on Radio Matariki, where Murienua’s Demo MP James Beer was talking with William ‘The Don’ Framhein regarding our country’s Mickey-Mouse economy and the challenges facing our people and country, their captivating and informative discussion really revved me up, and compelled me to write this letter supporting MP Beer’s rational arguments, further validating our concerns!

Businessman keen to see waste used

Monday 5 March 2018 | Published in Environment

Local business owner Brad Fraser is calling for the government and other business owners of Rarotonga to stand up and take responsibility for the island’s waste management.

Premium content

Youth council excited about workshop

Monday 5 March 2018 | Published in Local

The Cook Islands National Youth Council (CINYC) was excited when they received an expression of interest to host a confidence boosting workshop on Rarotonga from a United States based couple.

Premium content

Water experts build capacity

Monday 5 March 2018 | Published in Local

Not only is the Mei Te Vai Ki Te Vai project focused on improving the water quality of the lagoons in Rarotonga and Aitutaki – but on also building local capacity to contribute to the sustainability of the project.

Premium content

Water works running from Tupapa to Avana

Monday 5 March 2018 | Published in Local

The WATSAN Division of Infrastructure Cook Islands (ICI) will be undertaking work to replace underground galvanised service lines along the Ara Tapu mainroad, from the water supply sub main to the homes across the road in the Tupapa area before moving through to Avana in the coming weeks.

The great tax con

Monday 5 March 2018 | Published in Opinion

In previous weeks we have considered the fairness of our tax system, and with the recently passed legislation to write off taxes owing before January 1, 2010, why the integrity of our tax system fails. We then considered the legislation around late-payment penalties (additional tax), the write off of amounts deemed irrecoverable by the Collector, and the policies that the Revenue Management Division (RMD) have adopted over the years in relation to the reduction of additional tax. The ‘fresh start’ incentive and more recently the June 2017 tax amnesty were detailed. The comment has been made to me that it is a strange time when an accountant is batting for RMD. Strange times indeed! Even stranger times when Parliament passes legislation to legalise both tax evasion and tax theft! Taxpayers who have failed to file and those who have resisted paying (both being tax evasion), have been rewarded by the recent legislation. Those that have deducted PAYE from their workers (which is money held in trust to be paid to RMD on behalf of the workers) don’t have to pay it anymore, if taken from their workers before January 1, 2010 (that’s commonly called theft). The reasons (excuses) given by the government for the latest tax writeoff have been varied. Firstly, they wanted the tax liabilities off the Crown’s books. Then good taxpayers shouldn’t complain because they have enjoyed the recent good economic times, they said it was irrecoverable anyway, then it was to increase efficiencies as it was too time-consuming to follow up, then most was additional tax ($14m) so core tax was a small amount (only $5m), then the opposition didn’t care in helping people, and lately it included government departments owing. As everyone knows, if reasons for actions are changed, inconsistent or illogical, the truth is not being told. Few people are fooled by such excuses. Let us briefly consider each of these excuses. Firstly, to get rid of liabilities off the Crown’s book. Clearly wrong – receivables to anyone are assets not liabilities, so tax owed to the Crown is an asset to the government. Who wants to reduce their assets? Yes, the good compliant taxpayers have enjoyed the recent good economic times. But this is also due to their own investment in time and money. But the taxpayers that haven’t filed and haven’t paid have also benefitted from the recent good economic times. And still they haven’t bothered to pay their taxes. Next, it was irrecoverable debt. This is a real con. It appears the Chamber of Commerce has been fooled by this excuse. As noted in an earlier article, the Collector does write off any unpaid tax that is considered irrecoverable (pursuant to section 191 of the Income Tax Act 1997). The government should know, and the public needs to know, that the Collector regularly meets with senior management at RMD, reviews progress on tax arrears, and if there are valid reasons to do so, will write off any core tax. Nevertheless, it is important for RMD to have a long memory when it comes to tax arrears. For example, just because someone leaves the Cook Islands, their tax debt will not necessarily be written off straight away. Have no doubt – there are large amounts of tax dating from pre-2010 that were collectable. These debts were not too time-consuming to collect. With the June 2017 amnesty a number of these core tax debts would have been paid. It is well-recognised by governments that each dollar spent on resources in a tax department is returned many times over. Additional resources were needed, not a tax writeoff. Not only is the core tax paid, other taxpayers are dissuaded from getting into arrears. A few cases to the High Court sends a strong message to tax evaders. Then the excuse that most of the $19m was additional tax, so we should not worry about a “mere” $5m on core tax. This is quite illogical. Firstly, under the June 2017 amnesty all additional tax (not just the pre-2010 portion) would have been reversed. Secondly, $5m is a substantial sum that could have been put to good use. And thirdly, the figures quoted are only those known by RMD. There were still pre-2010 returns to be filed, and under the June amnesty these would have been filed, and the associated tax paid. When the opposition opposed the recent legislation in parliament, the reported government response was that the opposition didn’t care that people were leaving for overseas. The opposition “don’t care about those people”. That is an admission that some tax was collectable and that some people were going to benefit. But really, how many people do you know that have left the Cook Islands saying it was because the RMD was chasing them for their tax arrears? People leave for a number of reasons, but primarily because the cost of living is too high. Lowering the personal tax rates to benefit everyone would have been far better than benefitting a favoured few. The comment that government departments also owe tax is a poor reflection on those departments. While RMD chases the taxpayers in the private sector, what is done to make the negligent government departments comply? But wait, no, this week we are told they are up to date in paying, it was simply reconciliation errors. Seems like multi-choice here, and a mere smokescreen. Two facts are very clear. Most of the core tax was recoverable, and a few taxpayers are being let off massive amounts of core tax. There has been much comment in the media about why the core tax writeoff is wrong. Let’s consider a few major reasons. Firstly, it is a wrong against all employees. For all workers, salary and wages have PAYE deducted by their employer – no chance for a tax break there. Then they pay Value Added Tax (VAT) on almost all goods and services – power, telecom, food, petrol, etc. No tax breaks there. They pay 100 per cent of their tax. Next it is a wrong against all businesses that pay their taxes on time. By the 20th of each month they file their PAYE and VAT returns, and pay the tax. Income tax returns are filed regularly. Both provisional and terminal tax payments are made on time. No tax breaks here. They pay 100 per cent of their tax. Then it is a wrong against all the taxpayers that have made efforts to pay their arrears over the past few years. They have paid some additional and all their core tax. They have caught up with their obligations over the past few years. No writeoffs there. It is also a wrong against the government’s own employees, the RMD staff that have tried to get as many taxpayers compliant as possible. On February 6 I sent an email to the minister of finance and amongst other things said, “This (the writeoff of core tax) undermines years of work by RMD. What we need is strong tax administration, both now and going forward. Most of those with historical tax debts have ‘gamed the system’, and the public know this”. This week three senior employees have left RMD. More than 35 years of experience walked out the door. The timing is a coincidence? I think not. Finally, the tax writeoff is wrong as it rewards bad behaviour. Anyone who has any understanding of human behaviour, including most parents, will know that you will get more of the behaviour that you reward. Not only from the people rewarded, but also from the people that see the rewards. During the Global Financial Crisis, the term ‘moral hazard’ was coined. This was mainly in relation to the behaviour of the banks. The banks took risks, the owners pocketed the profits, but when things went pear-shaped, governments bailed them out. The ‘moral hazard’ was that by having governments save them, the banks were encouraged to continue to take risks. We have a similar situation here. Income tax is a percentage of profits. The taxpayers have made and pocketed the profit, and now the government has wiped out their associated tax. This sends a clear message to more than just the delinquent taxpayers. In a further email to the minister of finance dated February 7 I stated, “The writeoff benefits a few. A better response would have been to reduce the individual tax rates again, or increase the $11k exemption – that way everyone would have benefitted and, dare I say it, would have been politically smart. While many complain that market vendors, holiday homes and the construction industry are getting away with not paying, that pales into insignificance given the millions of dollars that are now being waived, of both assessed and yet to be assessed tax”. In closing, I recently mentioned to a senior government official that, given the obvious opposition to the write off of core tax, and being contrary to RMD’s advice, there must be significant political gains for the government to proceed with such legislation. The reply was, “or personal gain”. Indeed! - Mike Carr

Premium content

« Previous 1 … 138 139 140 141 142 143 144 145 146 … 1,715 Next »

More Top Stories

Articles by Utopia Support